Public Corporation in Administrative Law

Public Corporation in Administrative Law

Public corporation in Administrative Law are instrumental in carrying out governmental functions and providing public services that are critical for national development. They operate within the framework of administrative law, which ensures they function in a manner that is consistent with the public interest, transparent, and accountable to the people they serve. This paper explores the concept of public corporation in administrative law, examining their definition, characteristics, evolution, types, controls, and their role in the administrative structure of India.

Public Corporation in Administrative Law

Meaning of Public Corporation in Administrative Law

A public corporation is a legal entity created by the government to perform specific administrative functions, often related to public welfare, that could not be efficiently handled by the state alone. These corporations are endowed with special legal powers to manage and control certain activities on behalf of the government. Their operations are distinguished from those of private corporations in that their objectives often include public service rather than profit maximization.

A public corporation is created through an Act of Parliament or state legislation, and it enjoys a degree of autonomy in its day-to-day operations, although it remains accountable to the government. It may provide services like transportation, electricity, water supply, etc.

History and Background

The concept of public corporations began to take shape in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, especially in industrialized nations where state intervention in the economy became a norm. In India, the history of public corporations is linked to the post-independence period when the government sought to assume control over key sectors of the economy, such as power, transport, and manufacturing, to ensure equitable distribution of resources and promote national development.

The establishment of public corporations in India accelerated after the adoption of the Planning Commission and the Five-Year Plans, which identified key sectors of the economy that required public sector involvement for economic growth. As a result, several public sector undertakings (PSUs) were formed in strategic sectors such as steel, coal, and telecommunications.

Features of Public Corporation in Administrative Law

  1. Creation by Special Statute or Legislation:
    Public corporations are established by a specific Act of Parliament or state legislature, which defines their objectives, powers, and operational guidelines. This gives them legal recognition and authority to function independently within a set legal framework.
  2. Government Ownership:
    Public corporations are owned either by the central or state government, with the government often holding a majority of shares. This ensures their activities align with public welfare and national policy objectives.
  3. Autonomy in Management:
    Public corporations are granted considerable operational autonomy to manage their affairs, hire staff, make decisions, and conduct business without direct government interference, though they remain accountable to the government.
  4. Legal Personality:
    Public corporations are separate legal entities with the ability to enter into contracts, own property, sue, and be sued in their own name, distinct from the government.
  5. Public Purpose and Social Welfare Objective:
    The primary objective of public corporations is to serve the public interest, with a focus on providing public goods, services, and infrastructure, rather than generating profits.
  6. Accountability to Government and Public:
    While enjoying operational autonomy, public corporations are accountable to the government through oversight mechanisms, audits, and parliamentary scrutiny. They must also maintain transparency to the public, especially in matters of financial management.
  7. Commercial Activities:
    Public corporations often engage in commercial activities to achieve their public service objectives, such as generating revenue through providing services or selling products, though profit-making is not their primary goal.
  8. Separate Budget and Financial Autonomy:
    Public corporations typically have their own budget and financial management systems, with the flexibility to generate revenue from their activities while adhering to government financial regulations.
  9. Specialized Function:
    Public corporations are often established to perform specialized tasks that require technical expertise or large-scale investment, such as infrastructure projects, transportation, and energy production.
  10. Flexibility in Employment and Labor Relations:
    Public corporations have the autonomy to hire employees and set employment terms, often distinct from the government sector, though employees may enjoy similar benefits like pension schemes and job security.

Types of Public Corporation in Administrative Law

Public corporations are broadly categorized based on their nature, structure, and the laws under which they are established. These types include statutory corporations, government companies, and certain public authorities that function similarly to corporations but with some variations. Each type of public corporation operates under different legal frameworks, with varying degrees of autonomy and governance structures.

Statutory Corporations

Definition:

Statutory corporations are public corporations created by a specific Act of Parliament or state legislation. The law under which these corporations are created defines their powers, functions, and responsibilities. Statutory corporations typically enjoy considerable operational autonomy and are granted specific powers to carry out functions that are vital for public welfare.
Examples of Statutory Corporations in India:

  1. Indian Railways (under the Indian Railways Act, 1989)
  2. Food Corporation of India (FCI) (under the Food Corporation Act, 1964)
  3. Air India (under the Air Corporations Act, 1953, though now privatized)
  4. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL) (under the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885)
  5. National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC) (under the NTPC Act, 1975)

Government Companies

Definition:

A government company is a type of public corporation in Administrative Law in which the central or state government holds a majority (at least 51%) of the shares. These corporations are incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013, like any private company but are owned and controlled by the government.

Key Characteristics of Government Companies:

  • Ownership: The government holds a significant portion (51% or more) of the equity capital, which gives it control over the management and direction of the company.
  • Creation under the Companies Act: Government companies are formed and governed under the Companies Act, 2013, and are subject to the regulations applicable to private companies, with certain modifications for public sector enterprises.
  • Public Welfare Goals: While they are structured as companies, government companies typically pursue public welfare objectives in strategic sectors like energy, telecommunications, and heavy industry.

Examples of Government Companies:

  1. Oil and Natural Gas Corporation (ONGC) (under the Companies Act, 1956)
  2. Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited (BHEL) (under the Companies Act, 1956)
  3. Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL) (under the Companies Act, 1956)
  4. GAIL India Limited (under the Companies Act, 1956)

Public Authorities

Definition:

Public authorities refer to government agencies or bodies that perform specific functions similar to those of a public corporation but are not incorporated as companies or statutory corporations. These bodies may be established through executive orders, and their powers are often limited to specific tasks assigned by the government.

Key Characteristics of Public Authorities:

  • Executive Formation: Unlike statutory corporations, public authorities are typically set up by executive orders or decisions rather than through a legislative act.
  • Limited Autonomy: Public authorities usually have more limited autonomy than statutory corporations and may be directly controlled by a government ministry or department.
  • Public Service Functions: They generally focus on specific public service functions, such as regulating sectors or administering social welfare programs.
  • Accountability: Public authorities are usually accountable to the government or parliament, which oversees their operations and ensures compliance with relevant policies.

Examples of Public Authorities:

  1. Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC): Set up by the government of Delhi and the central government to manage the metro rail system in Delhi.
  2. Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI): Regulates telecommunications services in India, ensuring fair competition and consumer protection.
  3. Housing and Urban Development Corporation (HUDCO): A government authority that provides housing finance and development support for urban areas.

Government Trading Corporations

Definition:

Government trading corporations are public sector enterprises set up to engage in trade or business activities, with the government as the primary shareholder. They usually function in areas where commercial activity is required to achieve public policy objectives, such as import-export or the distribution of essential commodities.

Key Characteristic of Government Trading Corporations:

  • Public Welfare: Their activities often serve the public interest, such as controlling inflation by regulating essential commodity prices or providing goods in rural and remote areas.

Examples of Government Trading Corporations:

  1. The State Trading Corporation of India Ltd. (STC): Engaged in the export and import of essential goods, raw materials, and commodities.
  2. The Food Corporation of India (FCI): Involved in the procurement, storage, and distribution of food grains to ensure food security in India.
  3. The Minerals and Metals Trading Corporation of India (MMTC): Responsible for importing and exporting minerals and metals.

How do Public Corporations Differ from Government Departments in Terms of Governance?

Public corporations and government departments differ significantly in terms of governance:

  • Autonomy: Public corporations have greater operational autonomy than government departments. They function like private businesses and can make independent decisions on management, investments, and policy execution, although they are still subject to some government oversight.
  • Legal Status: Public corporations are independent legal entities with the power to enter contracts, sue, and be sued in their own name, whereas government departments are part of the administrative machinery of the government and do not have a separate legal identity.
  • Objectives: While government departments are generally focused on administering government policies and services, public corporations are typically set up to operate in specific sectors like energy, transportation, or manufacturing, with an emphasis on providing goods and services to the public.
  • Funding and Management: Public corporations often operate on a self-financing model, generating revenue through the sale of goods or services, while government departments are primarily funded through government budgets and do not operate with a focus on generating profit.

Public Corporation vs. Private Corporation

Feature

Public Corporation

Private Corporation

Ownership

Government is the primary or sole owner.

Owned by private individuals or entities.

Objective

Serve public interest, provide essential services.

Primarily profit-driven.

Funding

Financed by government and public funds.

Financed by private investors and capital markets.

Accountability

Accountable to government and the public.

Accountable to shareholders.

Legal Framework

Created through a statute.

Governed by the Companies Act, 2013 (India).

Autonomy

Autonomous in functioning, but with state control.

Operates independently of the government.

Various Controls Over the Functioning of Public Corporation in Administrative Law

Administrative law in India establishes several mechanisms to control and supervise the operations of public corporations. This article explores the various controls over the functioning of public corporations in India, including legislative, executive, financial, judicial, and other forms of control.

  1. Legislative Control Over Public Corporations
  2. Executive Control Over Public Corporations
  3. Judicial Control Over Public Corporations
  4. Financial and Audit Control Over Public Corporations

Legislative Control Over Public Corporations

Legislative control refers to the oversight and regulatory powers exercised by the Parliament or State Assemblies. These controls ensure that public corporations are operating within the scope of their legal mandates and adhere to public policy objectives. The main mechanisms for legislative control include:

Creation and Regulation Through Statutes

  • Public corporations in India are established by specific Acts of Parliament or state legislatures, which set out the legal framework for their functioning. These statutes define the objectives, structure, powers, and operational guidelines for each corporation.
  • These laws not only create public corporations but also regulate their activities, ensuring they align with government policies and objectives.
  • The legislature may amend these laws as necessary to address changing national priorities, technological advancements, or public expectations.

Parliamentary and State Legislative Scrutiny

Public corporation in Administrative Law are subject to regular scrutiny by the legislature, particularly through:

  • Annual Reports and Accounts: Public corporations are required to submit their annual reports, financial statements, and performance audits to Parliament or State Assemblies. These reports are debated in parliamentary committees, ensuring transparency and accountability.
  • Committee Oversight: Committees such as the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) and the Committee on Public Undertakings (COPU) scrutinize the operations, financial performance, and compliance of public corporations. They can call for explanations from the management of these corporations and make recommendations for improvements.
  • Debates and Discussions: Members of Parliament (MPs) or Members of Legislative Assemblies (MLAs) can raise issues related to the functioning of public corporations through debates, questions, or adjournment motions, compelling the government to respond.

Executive Control Over Public Corporations

Executive control refers to the authority exercised by the government, particularly the central and state executives, over public corporation in Administrative Law. While public corporation  enjoy a degree of autonomy, they are still subject to oversight by various government agencies.

Government Oversight and Appointment Powers

The government retains control over the strategic direction of public corporations through its powers to appoint key officials, including the Board of Directors, Chief Executives, and other senior management. These appointments are made either directly by the Ministry overseeing the corporation or through a selection process facilitated by the government.

  • Ministry Supervision: Each public corporation is assigned a central or state ministry that exercises oversight on behalf of the government. For example, the Ministry of Railways oversees the Indian Railways, while the Ministry of Power supervises the National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC).
  • Policy Direction: The government provides broad policy directions, guidelines, and performance expectations to public corporations. These guidelines ensure that the corporations align their activities with national economic policies and public welfare objectives.

Financial Control

The executive exercises control over the financial operations of public corporations, particularly through:

  • Budget Approvals: Public corporations often submit their annual budgets to the government for approval. The government can direct how funds are allocated to different areas and monitor the financial health of the corporation.
  • Subsidies and Grants: The government may provide financial support in the form of subsidies or grants to public corporations, particularly when they operate in sectors with high social utility but limited profitability, such as transportation or public health. This also involves the monitoring of how these funds are utilized.
  • Monitoring of Financial Performance: The Ministry of Finance, through the Department of Public Enterprises (DPE), monitors the financial performance of public corporations and ensures their alignment with fiscal policies.

Regulatory and Policy Directives

The executive also ensures that public corporations comply with national laws and regulations, including environmental norms, labor laws, and consumer protection laws. Government directives in these areas help ensure that public corporations operate ethically and efficiently.

Judicial Control Over Public Corporations

Judicial control in India ensures that public corporations act within the boundaries of the law, respect fundamental rights, and follow fair procedures. Public corporations, like any other state bodies, are subject to judicial review.

Judicial Review

The judiciary has the power to review the actions of public corporations to ensure they are not in violation of the Constitution, laws, or fundamental rights. Public corporations are considered “state” entities under Article 12 of the Constitution of India, which means that they are subject to the writ jurisdiction of the High Courts and the Supreme Court.

  • Writ Jurisdiction: Citizens can approach the courts for remedies through Public Interest Litigations (PILs) or writ petitions challenging arbitrary actions, illegal practices, or violations of fundamental rights by public corporations.
  • Principles of Natural Justice: Courts ensure that public corporations follow the principles of natural justice, especially in matters related to contract disputes, labour issues, or disciplinary proceedings against employees.

Enforcement of Accountability

The judiciary ensures that public corporations are accountable for any misuse of power or violation of law. For instance, the Supreme Court has ruled on the scope of accountability for public corporations, emphasizing that these entities cannot act arbitrarily or beyond the limits set by law.

Financial and Audit Control

Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) Audits

Public corporations in India are subject to audits by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG), an independent constitutional authority. The CAG conducts audits of public corporations to ensure financial transparency, compliance with legal norms, and effective use of public funds.

  • Performance Audit: The CAG also conducts performance audits to evaluate whether public corporations are achieving their objectives efficiently and economically.
  • Report Submissions: Audit reports are submitted to Parliament or the state legislature and are reviewed by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC).

Internal Audits and Reports

Public corporations are required to maintain their internal audit systems to monitor and assess financial operations regularly. These internal audits help detect and prevent financial irregularities or mismanagement. The internal audit reports are submitted to the management and the government for review.

Legal Frameworks Governing Public Corporation in Administrative Law in India

Public corporations in India are primarily governed by the statutes under which they are established. These laws provide the legal basis for their creation, powers, and functions. Some of the most significant statutory frameworks include:

The Companies Act, 2013

Public corporations that are government companies (where the government holds at least 51% of the shares) are governed by the Companies Act, 2013. Key provisions include:

  • Incorporation and Governance: Government companies are incorporated as private limited companies under the provisions of the Companies Act, but they have additional rules regarding the appointment of directors, management, and financial disclosure.
  • Financial Accountability: Government companies must prepare and submit their financial statements, and they are subject to audits by the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) of India.
  • Corporate Governance: The Act mandates the maintenance of corporate governance standards, ensuring transparency, fair practices, and accountability.

Statutory Corporations

Some public corporations are created by specific statutes passed by Parliament or state legislatures. These statutory corporations operate under the regulatory framework set out in their respective founding Acts. Some examples include:

  • Indian Railways: Governed by the Indian Railways Act, 1989, this statute provides the legal framework for the establishment, administration, and operation of the Indian Railways as a public corporation.
  • Food Corporation of India (FCI): Established under the Food Corporation Act, 1964, this statutory corporation is tasked with ensuring food security in the country by procuring, storing, and distributing food grains.
  • Bureau of Civil Aviation Security: Governed by the Civil Aviation Authority Act, 1994, this public corporation is responsible for regulating aviation security standards.

Public Enterprises (Management) Act, 1975

The Public Enterprises (Management) Act, 1975 provides guidelines for the management and control of public sector enterprises (PSEs), including public corporations. It aims to ensure that public corporations are managed efficiently, with accountability to both the government and the public.

The Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985

The Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 provides for the establishment of administrative tribunals to resolve disputes related to public sector employees and the functioning of public corporations. The Act empowers tribunals to handle cases such as:

  • Disciplinary proceedings against employees of public corporations.
  • Service disputes, including promotions, pay scales, and appointments within public corporations.
  • Recovery of claims related to the actions of public corporations.

These tribunals offer an alternative dispute resolution mechanism that is faster and more specialized than regular courts.

The Right to Information Act, 2005

The Right to Information (RTI) Act, 2005 is a crucial law that mandates public transparency and accountability. Under this Act, public corporations are obligated to:

  • Disclose information about their operations, finances, and decision-making processes upon request from citizens.
  • Establish public information officers who manage requests for information and ensure compliance with the Act.
  • Report annually on the implementation of the RTI Act, detailing the number of requests received, the information provided, and any refusals or denials.

The RTI Act helps increase transparency within public corporations, making them more accountable to the public and enhancing the overall governance system.

Financial Regulations and Policies

The functioning of public corporations is also governed by various financial regulations and policies that provide specific guidance on financial management, procurement, and investments. Some of the important regulatory instruments include:

General Financial Rules (GFR), 2017
The General Financial Rules (GFR), 2017 lay down guidelines for financial management in government organizations, including public corporations. Key aspects include:

  • Procurement guidelines: Outlining transparent and competitive processes for procurement and outsourcing.
  • Budgeting and expenditure: Providing instructions on how to prepare budgets and control expenditure.
  • Financial Reporting: Requiring regular financial reporting to ensure accountability and transparency in the utilization of public funds.

Public Procurement Policy

Public corporations are also subject to government procurement policies, which mandate that they follow transparent, competitive, and ethical procurement processes. This ensures that public funds are spent efficiently and that corruption and inefficiency are minimized.

Other Regulatory Frameworks

Depending on the sector in which a public corporation operates, additional regulatory frameworks may apply. Some examples include:

  • Environmental Regulations
    Public corporations in sectors such as energy and infrastructure are required to comply with environmental laws such as the Environment Protection Act, 1986, and the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981. These laws regulate their environmental impact, ensuring sustainable and eco-friendly operations.
  • Consumer Protection Laws
    Public corporations that provide essential services (e.g., water, electricity, telecom) must adhere to consumer protection laws such as the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which safeguards the rights of consumers and ensures the quality of services provided.
  • Labor Laws
    Public corporations must also comply with various labor laws, such as the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, Factories Act, 1948, and the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, which regulate worker rights, wages, conditions of employment, and social security benefits.

Control Mechanisms Over Public Corporation in Administrative Law

The control mechanisms in place for public corporations in India ensure that they are operated in a manner that aligns with public policy objectives. These mechanisms are designed to balance operational autonomy with accountability:

  • Internal Audits and Management Reports: Regular audits by both internal and external agencies ensure that public corporations follow legal and financial guidelines.
  • Ministry Oversight: Every public corporation has a nodal ministry that provides guidance and oversight regarding its operations, while the government ensures that it fulfils its public mandate.
  • Transparency Requirements: Public corporations are subject to extensive reporting requirements, and their records are open to public scrutiny through the Right to Information Act.
  • Independent Regulatory Authorities: For certain sectors (e.g., telecommunications, electricity), independent regulators oversee the performance of public corporations to ensure compliance with industry standards.

Role of Public Corporation in Administrative Law

Public undertakings are vital to the administrative framework as they provide essential services and contribute to national economic planning. Their role in administrative law is significant for several reasons:

  • Policy Implementation: Public corporations act as instruments for implementing government policies, particularly in sectors like infrastructure, education, healthcare, and energy.
  • Public Welfare: They ensure the equitable distribution of goods and services, especially in areas where private companies may not find it economically viable to operate.
  • Economic Development: Public corporations are crucial in driving economic growth, particularly in sectors that are capital-intensive, such as mining, energy, and heavy manufacturing.
  • Administrative Accountability: They contribute to ensuring that the government remains accountable to the people, as their actions and policies are scrutinized both by the legislature and the public.

Conclusion

Public corporations in India play a central role in the administration of public services and in fostering economic development. They are governed by a complex set of laws and regulations, ensuring that their operations align with the public interest. However, the challenge lies in maintaining a balance between operational autonomy and governmental control, so as to foster efficiency while ensuring accountability.In the future, these corporations will likely need to adapt to changing economic dynamics, technological advancements, and increasing demands for transparency and good governance. Thus, understanding and refining the legal and administrative framework governing public corporations remains a key aspect of ensuring their success in serving the public good.

Explore Law Shore: law notes today and take the first step toward mastering the fundamentals of law with ease.

Scroll to Top