Libel and Slander in Tort Law

Libel and Slander

Defamation is a civil wrong under the law of torts that involves the publication of false statements about an individual or entity, which damages their reputation. Defamation can take two distinct forms: libel and slander. Although both actions arise from defamatory statements, they differ in their form, manner of publication, and the legal consequences that follow. This article explores the differences between libel and slander, emphasizing the legal principles governing each, while also providing illustrations to aid understanding.

Libel and Slander

Defamation is an umbrella term that encompasses both libel and slander, where false statements made by one party harm the reputation of another. The law provides a remedy for individuals or entities whose reputation has been unjustly injured by defamatory statements. Defamation requires that the statement in question be communicated to a third party and that it harms the plaintiff’s reputation.

Libel

Libel refers to defamation that is published in a permanent form, such as written or printed words, images, or other visual representations. It includes media such as newspapers, books, television broadcasts, and photographs. Given that libelous statements exist in a fixed medium, they are considered to cause more enduring harm to the plaintiff’s reputation.

Libel is actionable per se, meaning that the claimant does not need to prove actual damage to their reputation. The mere publication of a defamatory statement in a permanent form suffices for a claim in libel.

Slander

Slander, conversely, pertains to defamatory statements made in a transitory form, such as spoken words, gestures, or other temporary representations. Slander typically involves verbal communications or non-permanent actions, like a defamatory gesture or a spoken allegation.

Unlike libel, slander is actionable only upon proof of actual damage, unless the defamatory statement falls under slander per se. Slander per se refers to defamatory statements that are so inherently damaging that harm to reputation is presumed, such as allegations of criminal conduct or contagious diseases.

Difference between Libel and Slander: A Comparative Analysis

The following table succinctly outlines the key differences between libel and slander in the context of defamation law:

Aspect

Libel

Slander

Nature

Defamation in permanent form

Defamation in transient form

Form of Communication

Written, printed, or visual representations

Spoken words or gestures

Examples

Newspaper articles, books, photographs, television programs

Oral statements, gestures, phone conversations

Actionability

Actionable per se (no need to prove damages)

Actionable only upon proving actual damages, except for slander per se

Harm

Considered more harmful due to permanence and wider dissemination

Generally considered less harmful, as it is temporary

Proof of Damage

No need to prove actual damage to reputation

Proof of actual damage is required unless the statement is slander per se

Legal Remedy

Compensatory and punitive damages

Compensatory damages, but proof of damages is often essential

Legal Principles: Libel and Slander with Illustrations

Libel

Libel involves defamatory statements that are made in a permanent medium, such as writing or visual representations. Given the enduring nature of libel, it is considered more harmful as it can reach a wider audience and persist over time. Additionally, libel is actionable per se, meaning that the plaintiff is not required to demonstrate actual harm to their reputation.

Illustration

  • A newspaper publishes a false statement that a well-known businessman is involved in embezzling funds. Since the statement is in a permanent form and widely disseminated, the businessman may sue for defamation under libel, without needing to provide proof of specific damage, as the mere publication of the defamatory content is sufficient to harm their reputation.
  • If a prominent television program airs a documentary falsely implicating an individual in criminal activity, the defamatory content, being in a permanent visual form, allows the person to file a claim for libel. The law presumes reputational damage due to the permanent and widespread nature of the broadcast.

Slander

Slander, by contrast, refers to defamatory statements made in a transitory form, such as spoken words or gestures. The law does not presume reputational damage in cases of slander, and the plaintiff must provide evidence of actual damage unless the statement falls under the category of slander per see.

Illustration

  • A person publicly accuses another of committing theft during a speech at a public event. If the statement is false, the person accused may bring a suit for slander. However, to succeed in the claim, the plaintiff must demonstrate that the slanderous remark caused measurable harm, such as loss of employment or business relationships.
  • If someone makes a false allegation that an individual is suffering from a contagious disease, the victim may bring a claim for slander per se, as the statement is considered inherently damaging to their reputation. In this case, actual damage need not be proven, as the defamatory nature of the statement is presumed.

Conclusion

The distinction between libel and slander lies primarily in the medium and form in which the defamatory statement is made. Libel involves permanent forms of defamation, such as written or printed words and images, and is actionable without proof of actual damage. On the other hand, slander involves transitory forms, such as spoken words and gestures, and generally requires proof of actual harm unless the statement falls within the scope of slander per see.

The law provides remedies for both forms of defamation, recognizing the damage that false statements can inflict on a person’s reputation. However, the legal treatment differs due to the nature of the medium in which the defamatory statement is conveyed. As such, individuals who believe their reputation has been damaged by either libel or slander may seek redress in a court of law, subject to the specific requirements and elements of each type of defamation.

Explore Law Shore: law notes today and take the first step toward mastering the fundamentals of law with ease.

Scroll to Top